MakeMeACoin is for
Founders who want a connected mint → score → revoke → LP path with a shareable /score/{mint} URL and flat SOL fees shown before signing.
Smithii is for
Users who want a wide marketplace of Solana (and other-chain) utilities, including bots and extras MMAC does not ship.
Feature comparison
| Feature | MakeMeACoin | Smithii |
|---|---|---|
| Token creation | Classic SPL mint on the Solana token creator — $0 platform fee when authorities kept | Solana token creator in the Smithii catalog — verify live options (SPL / extras) |
| No-code workflow | Form + wallet sign; then score, revoke, LP in the same product | No-code tool grid — each utility is typically a separate tool page |
| Price model | Flat per-action SOL; mint $0 platform fee by default | Per-tool SOL fees published on smithii.io / tools.smithii.io — amounts have varied; verify live |
| Network fees | Solana rent + gas always extra; shown as an estimate before you sign | Network costs apply on top of tool fees — verify how each tool quotes them |
| Custody | Non-custodial — MMAC never holds keys | Wallet-connected tools; verify custody per tool |
| Wallet signing | Phantom, Solflare, or Backpack signs every tx | Wallet-signed flows — verify supported wallets on their creator |
| Authority management | Keep mint/freeze at create (default) or revoke later | Creator typically leaves authorities with your wallet; optional revokes — verify current form |
| Revoke tools | Mint 0.075 SOL, freeze 0.075 SOL, both 0.12 SOL in one tx | Separate revoke actions appear on Smithii docs/tools — verify current SOL each |
| Liquidity tools | Create Raydium CPMM at /lp (0.1 SOL platform fee). No native LP locker | Liquidity / pool tools exist in the catalog — verify venue and fee |
| Safety / rug analysis | Launch Score + Token Inspector risk flags (not an audit) | Not documented as a public shareable score page — verify independently |
| Launch scoring | Public /score/{mint} with recommendations | No equivalent documented as a core Smithii product |
| API availability | Public Launch Score API at /docs/score-api | Verify whether Smithii exposes a comparable public score API |
| Transparency | SSOT prices on /pricing; fee shown pre-sign; atomic paid actions | Fees shown per tool — re-check the same day you pay |
| UX | Short Solana-only funnel: create, score, fix, LP | Large catalog — better if you need many unrelated utilities |
| Volume / market-maker bots | Not offered as a core launch product | Offered in Smithii catalog — verify |
Pricing comparison
| Item | MakeMeACoin | Smithii |
|---|---|---|
| Basic SPL mint | $0 platform fee (authorities kept) | Official creator pages have listed different totals (docs vs tools). Verify on smithii.io / tools.smithii.io |
| Revoke mint | 0.075 SOL | Revoke mint listed as a separate paid action on Smithii docs — verify live |
| Revoke freeze | 0.075 SOL | Revoke freeze listed as a separate paid action on Smithii docs — verify live |
| Revoke both | 0.12 SOL atomic | Usually two revoke actions — add them yourself from the live tool |
| Burn SPL supply | 0.03 SOL | Verify current burn tool |
| Raydium CPMM pool | 0.1 SOL platform fee | Liquidity tool fee — verify live (FAQ/tools pages have differed) |
| Launch Score | Free public page | No documented equivalent core product |
| Snapshot Holders | Free CSV at /snapshot-holders | Verify Smithii snapshot / holder tools |
| Vanity Generator | Free browser-side at /vanity | Verify Smithii vanity offering |
Launch Score difference
MakeMeACoin includes a public Launch Score URL at /score/{mint} — a shareable trust page with authority checks, risk flags, and recommendations. Verify whether Smithii offers an equivalent public trust page for your workflow.
When to pick which
Pick MakeMeACoin when
Pick MakeMeACoin if public Launch Score, $0 platform mint, and a short post-mint trust checklist matter more than a large tool catalog. Walk through how MakeMeACoin minting works.
Pick Smithii when
Pick Smithii if you specifically need a Smithii-only tool (volume/market-maker bots, multi-chain catalog, or their launchpad extras). Verify that tool’s current fee on smithii.io before paying.
MakeMeACoin focus
- Public Launch Score URLs at /score/{mint}
- Connected vanity → mint → snapshot → revoke → LP funnel
- Transparent SSOT pricing for revoke, burn, and Raydium CPMM
- Non-custodial wallet signing throughout
Limitations
- MMAC does not claim to be cheaper or better on every action — Smithii’s published creator and LP totals have changed; verify on smithii.io the day you pay.
- Smithii has a wider tool catalog (including bots and multi-chain utilities) that MMAC does not ship.
- MMAC does not lock liquidity, run swaps, or operate volume bots.
- Launch Score is a public signal — not a formal audit or safety guarantee.
FAQ
Is MakeMeACoin a Smithii alternative?
Yes for founders who want Launch Score and a mint → score → revoke → LP funnel. It is not a drop-in replacement for Smithii’s full marketplace. See also /docs/is-makemeacoin-a-smithii-alternative and the MakeMeACoin mint walkthrough.
Which has Launch Score?
MakeMeACoin includes public Launch Score URLs at /score/{mint}. Verify independently whether Smithii offers an equivalent shareable page.
Where is the broad tools alternative page?
/smithii-tools-alternative summarizes marketplace differences; /smithii-token-creator-alternative focuses on minting; the MakeMeACoin mint walkthrough is the live creator.
Other comparisons
Next steps
Related tools
Related guides
The Solana launch trust layer — free mint, public Launch Score, paid trust actions.